Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Legislation

Big tobacco uses The Castle in legal blue

http://www.news.com.au/breaking-news/big-tobacco-uses-the-castle-in-legal-blue/story-e6frfku0-1226136212203

BIG tobacco says the federal government’s plan to ban company branding on cigarette packs is as unjust as the commonwealth’s attempt to acquire Darryl Kerrigan’s home in the Australian film The Castle.

British American Tobacco Australia has told a Senate inquiry that Labor’s plain-packaging legislation is badly drafted and unfair.

Top silk Allan Myers QC said today the draft laws would “extinguish the most valuable uses of trademarks” without compensation.

“If the parliament wants to enact plain-packaging legislation, it’s pretty simple – they face up to the fact that they’re taking people’s property away and pay for it,” Mr Myers told the committee hearing in Canberra.

“The trademark in a broad sense is being appropriated for the benefit of the commonwealth.

“The acquisition of property simply doesn’t refer to marching in and taking someone’s house like in The Castle or some film.”

But other legal experts, including officials from the attorney-general’s and health departments, disagree.

Melbourne University law professor Simon Evans essentially told Mr Myers he was dreaming.

Prof Evans agreed trademarks were considered property under section 51(xxxi) of the constitution and they could not be acquired without just compensation.

But he argued the commonwealth was not acquiring the brands but rather restricting their use.

Prof Evans also drew on Darryl Kerrigan’s fictional battle to make his point.

“It’s not like The Castle where the commonwealth gets the benefit of the house in order to operate the airport,” the academic said.

“On current authority there is very little prospect that the High Court would conclude that the plain-packaging legislation effects an acquisition of those property rights.”

Prof Evans said there was “very little risk” big tobacco would win a High Court challenge because there was no transfer of property and the government would not use the trade mark.

Health department general counsel Chris Reid agreed.

“The department is quite confident here that there would not be an acquisition of property,” he said.

Australian National University law professor Matthew Rimmer told Tuesday’s hearing the same argument applied in relation to international intellectual property rights agreements.

The Gillard government wants all cigarettes to be sold in drab olive-brown packs from mid-2012.

It has two bills before parliament to make that happen: the main legislation and an associated bill to amend the Trade Marks Act.

Both have already passed the lower house and are expected to sail through the Senate with the support of the Greens.

BATA has said it will challenge the laws, once passed, in court.

Read more: http://www.news.com.au/breaking-news/big-tobacco-uses-the-castle-in-legal-blue/story-e6frfku0-1226136212203#ixzz1XsQqp300

Call to bar alcohol and tobacco from TPP

http://www.nbr.co.nz/article/call-bar-alcohol-and-tobacco-tpp-cw-100374

Colin Williscroft | Monday September 12, 2011

Trans Pacific Partnership negotiators have been told to exclude alcohol and tobacco from any agreement.

The executive vice-president of the American Medical Association (AMA) James Madara wrote to US trade representative Ron Kirk urging the exclusion of tobacco and alcohol products from all provisions of TPP and any other free trade agreement.

“Removing trade barriers may be a desirable objective when the products being traded are beneficial, but tobacco is not a beneficial product,” Mr Madara said.

“Cigarettes are the only legally available consumer product that kills through its intended normal use.”

The letter cited longstanding AMA policy that “international trade agreements recognise that health and public health concerns take priority over commercial interests, and that trade negotiations be conducted in a transparent manner and with full attention to health concerns and participation by the public health community’’.

The exclusion would prevent actions like that of cigarette manufacturer Philip Morris, which has sued the governments of Uruguay and Australia for their tobacco control policies.

It would also mean intellectual property rules would not apply to tobacco and alcohol trademarks, and governments would not be required to reduce their current tariffs on imports, Professor Jane Kelsey, associate dean from the Auckland University law school said. Prof Kelsey was at the TPP negotiations in Chicago.

FDA to Big Tobacco: You already lost fight over graphic labels

http://newsandinsight.thomsonreuters.com/Legal/News/ViewNews.aspx?id=27413&terms=%40ReutersTopicCodes+CONTAINS+’ANV‘

If you haven’t already seen the images that the Food and Drug Administration will require tobacco companies to include on cigarette packages, take a look. They’re disgusting: rotting teeth and gums, blackened lungs, a patient with a Frankenstein scar running down his chest. Congress’s 2009 Smoking Prevention and Tobacco Control Act, the first update of cigarette warning labels since 1984, was supposed to give the FDA the power to depict the health consequences of smoking with color graphics. These labels, approved in June after a two-year rule-making process, sure do that.

In August, a group of tobacco companies claimed that the new labels violate the industry’s constitutional rights. In a 41-page complaint filed in Washington, D.C., federal district court, the tobacco companies argued that the labels are an unprecedented attempt to force them to serve as mouthpieces for the government’s anti-smoking message. “This is precisely the type of controlled speech that the First Amendment prohibits,” the complaint claimed. “While the government may require plaintiffs to provide purely factual and uncontroversial information to inform consumers about the risks of tobacco products, it may not require [tobacco companies] to advocate against the purchase of their own lawful products.”

The complaint asks for a declaratory judgment that the tobacco labels are unconstitutional and a preliminary injunction blocking the FDA from implementing the new labeling rules.

But as the FDA pointed out in a 55-page response Friday, there’s a bit of a roadblock in the industry’s way. To win a preliminary injunction, the tobacco companies have to show that they’re likely to succeed on the merits of their First Amendment argument. That will be very tough, the FDA argued, since they’ve already lost that case. In 2009, three of the plaintiffs in the declaratory judgment suit were part of a different coalition of tobacco companies that sued the FDA in Bowling Green, Ky., federal court, raising First and Fifth Amendment challenges to the Tobacco Control Act. Ruling on cross-motions for summary judgment (after denying Big Tobacco’s preliminary injunction bid), Judge Joseph McKinley Jr., upheld the law’s constitutionality in a Jan. 10, 2010 ruling. (Both sides appealed aspects of the ruling; the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit heard the appeal in July.)

The FDA argued that the new suit is simply a reboot of the old, failed case. “Plaintiffs’ new suit reprises arguments already considered and rejected in [the previous suit],” the filing said.

The tobacco companies-which represented by a crackerjack lineup of law firms, including Jones Day;Cahill Gordon & Reindel; Latham & Watkins; O’Melveny & Myers; and Covington & Burling-claim that the new suit is different from the old one because when they first sued, the FDA hadn’t settled on precisely which images tobacco products would carry. The FDA has countered that the industry considers any color graphic to be a violation of its First Amendment rights-an issue Judge McKinley has already decided.

D.C. judge Richard Leon will have to sort the whole thing out. I’ll let you know when he does.

(Reporting by Alison Frankel)

New Law Lets Landlords Ban Smoking

http://manhattanbeach.patch.com/articles/new-law-lets-landlords-ban-smoking-3

Gov. Jerry Brown signs Senate Bill 332, which allows landlords to prohibit smoking in rental units.

By Meredith Skrzypczak

California renters might soon face new smoking rules after Gov. Jerry Brown Wednesday signed a bill that would allow landlords to ban smoking in apartments and other rental units.

The law goes into effect on Jan. 1, 2012.

“With the Governor’s action today, we will see the availability of smoke-free, multi-family housing grow throughout California,” said state Sen. Alex Padilla, D-Pacoima, who authored the measure, in a statement Wednesday. “While more than 86 percent of Californians do not smoke, there is currently very little smoke-free housing in California. Living in multi-family housing should not compromise the health of renters or their children. This new law will provide tenants with healthier choices.”

While landlords can restrict pets, noise and specific furniture, such as waterbeds, there is nothing in current law that allows a landlord to restrict smoking

Smoke and mirrors: how the tobacco industry hides behind lobbyists

http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/smoke-and-mirrors-how-the-tobacco-industry-hides-behind-lobbyists-2348402.html

The tobacco industry is covertly using third-party companies to lobby against smoking restrictions and to gain access to health documents held by public organisations.

Public relations companies and law firms are working on behalf of anonymous multinational tobacco companies without declaring who their clients are, according to an investigation by The Independent.

The third parties have refused to confirm they are working on behalf of tobacco firms when they make freedom of information requests from universities and other public bodies, even though the third parties are demanding more openness from their targets.

The public relations company Bell Pottinger and the London law firm Clifford Chance have both requested information from public organisations without making it clear they are working on behalf of tobacco firms.

The Irish PR company Hume Brophy has also carried out a lobbying campaign against the Government’s ban on cigarette displays in shops on behalf of the National Federation of Retail Newsagents without stating that the campaign was being funded by the tobacco industry.

The Independent has established that Alex Deane, a former chief-of-staff to David Cameron, played a key role in attempts to use the freedom of information law against one public organisation involved in promoting awareness against the health dangers of roll-up tobacco. Mr Deane is a director of Bell Pottinger which earlier this year requested documents from a health-awareness organisation funded by the NHS, the Bristol-based Smoke Free South West, following a campaign it ran against roll-up tobacco, which is popular in that part of the country.

Soon after this informal request, Smoke Free South West received a formal freedom of information request for the same documentation from Big Brother Watch, a right-of-centre libertarian group founded by Mr Deane.

Neither Bell Pottinger nor Big Brother Watch declared to Smoke Free South West that they had held discussions with one another or with Bristol-based Imperial Tobacco, which is listed as one of Bell Pottinger’s clients in the PR firm’s website, and makes Golden Virginia rolling tobacco and Rizla cigarette papers.

Mr Deane was not available for comment yesterday; Bell Pottinger said he was on holiday. David Petrie, the Bell Pottinger executive who sent the email requests to Smoke Free South West, did not return calls. Daniel Hamilton, a director of Big Brother Watch, refused to confirm or deny that his organisation had been in contact with Bell Pottinger or Imperial Tobacco over the FOI request to Smoke Free South West. “We don’t work on behalf of other groups. We only work on behalf of ourselves… We’ve got no formal links with anyone in the tobacco industry,” Mr Hamilton said.

This week, The Independent revealed that tobacco companies had demanded access to confidential university research papers on teenagers’ attitudes to smoking, as well as meetings within the Department of Health between government officials and experts on smoking and health.

Stirling University, which carries out research on behalf of the Health Department and Cancer Research UK, said Philip Morris, the makers of Marlboro cigarettes, was attempting to access thousands of confidential interviews with British teenagers.

The FOI request was initially made in 2009 through the London law firm Clifford Chance, which tried to keep the identify of its client confidential. However, under the Scottish Freedom of Information Act, which is slightly different to the English Act, a third party must name the client it is working for – in this case Philip Morris.

A spokeswoman for Clifford Chance said she could not comment on whether the law firm was carrying out any further freedom of information requests on behalf of tobacco companies. Under the English FOI Act, third parties can work on behalf of anonymous clients.

Hume Brophy, the Irish public relations company, admitted it was a mistake to conduct a parliamentary lobbying campaign against cigarette displays in shops without making it clear it was paid for by the tobacco industry. In a letter to Stephen Williams MP, John Hume, a partner in the company, said that it will not happen again.

Martin Dockrell of the campaign group Action on Smoking and Health said that the tobacco industry’s use of “front” organisations was nothing new.

“Big Tobacco’s dirty little secret is how they get others to do their dirty work,” Mr Dockrell said. “Some front groups are pretty much wholly owned subsidiaries; some appear to be independent but tobacco companies pay the bills and pull the strings.”

Former Cameron crony leading the fight for the smoking lobby

Profile

Alex Deane served as David Cameron’s chief of staff when Cameron was shadow education secretary from 2004-2005. A Tory activist since 1995, Mr Deane is now a director of Bell Pottinger, the public relations firm set up by Lord Bell, the Tory peer. He was a founding director of Big Brother Watch, a right-of-centre libertarian pressure group that opposes state-controlled surveillance and what it sees as intrusions into civil liberties. He has opposed CCTV cameras, DNA databases, council surveillance and data chips in dustbins. Big Brother Watch also stoutly defends the rights of smokers to smoke in public places.

Tobacco industry’s smokescreen in packaging debate

http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/7a29371a-d53f-11e0-bd7e-00144feab49a.html#axzz1XDdECaxu

Tobacco manufacturers generally have a hard time trying to seize the moral high ground. But that is what is happening in Australia, where the Senate, the upper house of parliament, will decide in the next couple of weeks whether to approve the world’s toughest anti-smoking legislation.

Under the Labor government’s proposals, all tobacco products would have to be sold in identical plain green packaging, without logos or design variations. Brand and product names would be in identical type, making it very hard to target specific market segments such as women or young adults.

This draconian plan, already approved by parliament’s lower house, has triggered a furious assault from British American Tobacco, the market leader with 46 per cent of sales, and the smaller players Philip Morris and Imperial Tobacco, which share most of the rest of the market. BAT says it will challenge the law immediately in Australia’s High Court if it passes in the upper house. This is a serious threat: only last week the court struck down a key plank of Australia’s foreign policy because it conflicted with elements of Australian and international law.

Superficially, the fuss is surprising. From the perspective of the big international tobacco companies, Australia is a tiny market, its $7.9bn of sales accounting for just 1.8 per cent of the global total in 2010, according to a study by Deloittepublished in February.

But Big Tobacco has a broader view. Australia is not the only advanced economy thinking about plain packaging. Many have looked at it, and it is being actively considered in Canada, the UK and the European Union. Australian backing might give the idea fresh traction across the developed world.

The legislation has substantial support. The plain packaging bill was supported unanimously in the lower house, though the conservative opposition unsuccessfully opposed a separate, but linked, trademark bill. An opinion poll for The Australian in August showed 48 per cent public support for plain packaging.

Bowing to science, the tobacco companies no longer claim that their product is harmless. In evidence to a parliamentary inquiry in June, BAT Australia said there was “no question that smoking tobacco can cause serious and fatal disease”, adding that the only way to avoid the risks was not to smoke.

Yet the industry is not bereft of arguments. One is that the government’s proposal is not based on evidence. It cannot be, since no other country has tried such an approach. But there is some evidence that graphic warnings on packs have had little or no impact on people’s propensity to smoke.

A second is that the legislation is unnecessary. Australia has a range of measures limiting the marketing and sale of tobacco, and the incidence of smoking is already falling steadily. The government’s Institute of Health and Welfarereported in July that only 15.1 per cent of Australians over 14 smoked daily in 2010, down from 25 per cent in 1993.

The tobacco lobby says this trend could reverse because prices will fall as the constraints on marketing make it hard to charge more for premium brands – one of the main drivers of profit.

Customers may also be more attracted to illegal unbranded cigarettes. BAT also says the legislation would conflict with various bilateral trade agreements, Australian law on trademark ownership and World Trade Organisation rules.

The most powerful argument, though, is that parliament is usurping the rights of adults to choose between competing legal products – deciding, in effect, that nanny knows best – while simultaneously breaching the tobacco companies’ constitutional rights by prohibiting the use of their intellectual property.

These are not empty arguments. But they are not conclusive either. Restricting choice may be illiberal but parliament is entitled to prioritise public health. If the policy is not well-founded, or fails to achieve its objective, the voters have the remedy. None of the peripheral legal challenges to plain packaging is insoluble, though some might require further changes to the law if challenges are upheld.

That leaves the constitutional issue, which is presented as a matter of principle but is really a matter of cost. Like most other advanced countries, Australia allows appropriation of property assets but requires “just terms”. That means there may have to be negotiations about compensation, which BAT suggests might be in the vicinity of A$3bn. But blocking the use of tobacco companies’ intellectual property is no different in principle from the acquisition of farming land for highways.

From the point of view of their shareholders, the tobacco companies are right to fight. If the Australian proposals are implemented, similar laws will emerge elsewhere, with damaging effects on profits. But that is an argument located in the wallet, not on the moral high ground. It is not a reason for the Senate to vote No.

Kevin Brown is the FT’s Asia Regional Correspondent

What the paper said: Smoking ban in Tassie; New bar culture for Perth;

http://www.hospitalitymagazine.com.au/article/What-the-paper-said-Smoking-ban-in-Tassie-New-bar-culture-for-Perth/531158.aspx

TasPorts in firing line over smoking

Tasports should ban smoking in alfresco dining areas in its jurisdiction, a leading public health specialist says. Heart Foundation president Peter Sexton yesterday called on TasPorts to help support efforts to reduce the high rate of tobacco smoking in Tasmania. “TasPorts had an ideal opportunity to use the powers available under section 67B of the Public Health Act 1997, to support the Hobart City Council indesignating alfresco entertainment areas smoke-free,” Dr Sexton said. The Hobart City Council has banned smoking in outdoor dining areas at restaurants, cafes and pubs in Salamanca and pockets of North Hobart and South Hobart. Since the smoking ban came into place on August 1 there has been confusion over how the rules apply, with smoking still allowed in areas of Elizabeth St Pier, Murray St Pier and Victoria and Constitution docks, which come under the jurisdiction of TasPorts. Dr Sexton said smoking rates in Tasmania were significantly higher than in mainland states. About 23 per cent of Tasmanian adults are either daily or occasional smokers, compared with about 19 per cent nationally. Hobart Mercury, August 15.

FDA Regulation of Tobacco Products: A Historical, Policy and Legal Analysis

Abstract. This report examines the legislative debate over giving FDA the authority to regulate tobacco
products and provides some analysis of H.R. 1108/S. 625. It begins with an overview of the FDA’s 1996 tobacco
rule that includes a summary of the agency’s arguments for asserting jurisdiction over tobacco products. That is
followed by an analysis of the U.S. Supreme Court decision in FDA v. Brown & Williamson, which overturned
the FDA tobacco rule. The report then reviews the 1997 proposed national tobacco settlement, which would
have codified the FDA rule and given the agency explicit authority to regulate tobacco products as medical
devices. It includes a discussion of the FDA provisions in the McCain tobacco bill (see Table 1), which was
introduced and debated in the 105th Congress in an attempt to implement the proposed settlement. The final
section of the report summarizes the legislative history and provisions of H.R. 1108/S. 625 (see Table 2), and
discusses some of the key issues, including preemption and the regulation of reduced-risk products.

Abstract. This report examines the legislative debate over giving FDA the authority to regulate tobaccoproducts and provides some analysis of H.R. 1108/S. 625. It begins with an overview of the FDA’s 1996 tobaccorule that includes a summary of the agency’s arguments for asserting jurisdiction over tobacco products. That isfollowed by an analysis of the U.S. Supreme Court decision in FDA v. Brown & Williamson, which overturnedthe FDA tobacco rule. The report then reviews the 1997 proposed national tobacco settlement, which wouldhave codified the FDA rule and given the agency explicit authority to regulate tobacco products as medicaldevices. It includes a discussion of the FDA provisions in the McCain tobacco bill (see Table 1), which wasintroduced and debated in the 105th Congress in an attempt to implement the proposed settlement. The finalsection of the report summarizes the legislative history and provisions of H.R. 1108/S. 625 (see Table 2), anddiscusses some of the key issues, including preemption and the regulation of reduced-risk products.

DOWNLOAD PDF : 2239

Plain Cigarette Packaging and the Law – Will it Work? – Analyst Insight from Euromonitor International

http://blog.euromonitor.com/2011/08/plain-cigarette-packaging-and-the-law-will-it-work.html#more

On the other hand, a year after the introduction of graphic health warnings, smoking prevalence in New Zealand has fallen from 25% to 20%. Although the warnings are not regarded as the only factor impacting sales they are regarded as significant and evidence that smokers are asking for packs with less disturbing warning pictures on them is taken as supporting this.

The Euromonitor International view is that plain packaging would be a massive blow to the tobacco companies and would also have an effect on prevalence (because tobacco brands are so iconic and traditional), albeit not a very significant one. Plain packaging could have a much greater effect on major cigarette brands and the inclination of smokers to buy them, thus its widespread adoption would probably mean we would see the proportion of international brands in the product mix

Laws Banning Smoking in Vehicles Carrying Children – International Overview

Canadian Cancer Society

August 30, 2011

Summary: Laws prohibiting smoking in vehicles carrying children have been adopted in 9 Canadian provinces/territories (British Columbia, Saskatchewan, Manitoba, Ontario, New Brunswick, Nova Scotia, Prince Edward Island, Newfoundland and Labrador, and the Yukon Territory); 8 Canadian municipalities – Wolfville (Nova Scotia), Surrey (British Columbia), White Rock (B.C.), Richmond (B.C.), Okotoks (Alberta), Athabasca (Alberta), Leduc (Alberta), Medicine Hat (Alberta); 6 Australian states – South Australia, Tasmania, New South Wales, Victoria, Queensland and Western Australia; 4 U.S. states – California, Maine, Arkansas, and Louisiana; 10 U.S. municipalities – Bangor (Maine), Keyport (New Jersey), West Long Branch Borough (New Jersey), Rockland County (New York), Monroe County (Indiana), Rohnert Park (California), Martinez (California), Hawaii county (Hawaii), as well as South Africa, Mauritius, Bahrain, and Puerto Rico.  It may be that other jurisdictions have also adopted laws.

Listed below are the jurisdictions, the applicable age, the date of coming into force.  Applicable age refers to under the age, thus “19” (for example) means that smoking is prohibited in a vehicle carrying someone under age 19.


Countries

1. Mauritius (18+ [i], Mar. 1, 2009)

2. South Africa (12, Aug. 21, 2009)

3. Bahrain 2

Canadian provinces/territories (9 of 13)

1. Nova Scotia (19, Apr. 1, 2008)

2. Yukon Territory (18, May 15, 2008)

3. Ontario (16, Jan. 21, 2009)

4. British Columbia (16, Apr. 7, 2009)

5. New Brunswick (16,   Jan. 1, 2010)

6. Prince Edward Island (19, Sept. 15, 2009)

7. Manitoba (16, July 15, 2010)

8. Saskatchewan (16, Oct. 1, 2010)

9. Newfoundland and Labrador (16, July 1, 2011)

Canadian municipalities (8)

1. Wolfville, Nova Scotia (19, June 1, 2008)

2. Surrey, British Columbia (19, July 31, 2008)

3. Okotoks, Alberta (16, Sept. 1, 2008)

4. White Rock, British Columbia (16, Nov. 1, 2008)

5. Richmond, British Columbia           (19, Nov. 30, 2008)

6. Athabasca, Alberta (18, Mar. 22, 2011)

7. Leduc, Alberta (18, July 2, 2011)

8. Medicine Hat, Alberta (16, Sept. 1, 2011)

Australian states and territories (6 of 8)

1. South Australia (16, May 31, 2007)

2. Tasmania (18, Jan. 1, 2008)

3. New South Wales (16, July 1, 2009)

4. Victoria (18, Jan. 1, 2010)

5. Queensland (16, Jan. 1, 2010)

6. Western Australia (17, Sept. 23, 2010)

U.S. states (4 of 50)

1. Arkansas (if car seat required,3 July 21, 2006)

2. Louisiana (13,4 Aug. 15, 2006)

3. California (18, Jan. 1, 2008)

4. Maine (16, Sept. 1, 2008)

U.S. municipalities (9)

1. Bangor, Maine (18, Jan. 18, 2007)

2. Keyport, New Jersey (18, Apr. 26, 2007)

3. Rockland County, N.Y.  (18, June 21, 2007)

4. West Long Branch Borough, NJ (18, June 9, 2007)

5. Loma Linda, CA (18, July 24, 2008)

6. Monroe County, Indiana (13, April 8, 2009)

7. Rohnert Park, CA (18, May 28, 2009)

8. Martinez, CA (18, June 5, 2009)

9. Hawaii County, Hawaii (18, Aug. 8, 2010)

10. Carpenteria, CA (18, May 16, 2011)

Other

1. Puerto Rico (13, Mar. 2, 2007)

(US Commonwealth in Caribbean)

DOWNLOAD PDF : INTERNATIONAL OVERVIEW international overview-2011-08-30-vehicles with kids