Clear The Air News Tobacco Blog Rotating Header Image

Legislation

Tobacco lobby threatens EU over plain packaging

EU Health Commissioner John Dalli will face legal action if he tries to reproduce Australia’s plain-packaging proposals for cigarettes in Europe, a tobacco industry representative warned this week.

The Australian rules would force tobacco companies to sell cigarettes in buff packaging free of trademarks and logos but carrying dominant pictorial health warnings.

Australian senators approved the legislation today (10 November), but amendments must still be approved by the lower house before becoming law in December 2012.

Dalli is preparing an impact assessment of policy options in advance of the European Commission’s own review of its 2001 Tobacco Products Directive. The review is scheduled for early next year.

Various ideas, including plain packaging, are being considered within this process and the tobacco industry, retailers and distributors, are nervous that the Maltese Commissioner will be tempted to follow the Australian example – the first of its kind.

A spokeswoman for Dalli, himself a reformed smoker, said that the Commission has not yet made up its mind on plain packaging, but added that it was following the Australian development “carefully and with interest”.

Warnings from retailers

A working group organised by the federation of tobacco retailers (CEDT) meeting in Brussels on Tuesday (8 November) blasted plain packaging and claimed that the Commission’s health officials were not listening to industry or retailers on the issue.

CEDT President Giovanni Risso said that if measures such as display bans, plain packaging, oversized health warnings and bans on ingredients were introduced, these could result in a loss of up to €20 billion in European tax revenue.

Meeting representatives also said that smugglers and counterfeit manufacturers would increase their already burgeoning activity as a result of plain packaging.

One retailing representative told the meeting: “Dalli has no authority to introduce harmonisation of retail in this way using the Single Market Act, since there have been no complaints about distortions in the market. There is no competence here.”

The question of legal authority was later stressed by another source close to the tobacco industry, who told EurActiv: “We will take him to court if he tries to introduce it (plain packaging) and we are confident we would have a good case.”

In Australia, British American Tobacco (BAT) said it would initiate legal action in the nation’s top court in a bid to repeal the upcoming plain packaging law, claiming it is unconstitutional.

Industry getting jittery in advance of proposals

Plain packaging is one of the key areas of concern of industry, distributors and retailers as the Commission’s impact assessment takes place. EurActiv understands that a number of meetings have been arranged in Brussels for later this month in which tobacco industry representatives will discuss proposals and strategy with MEPs and consultants.

One likely focus of attack is intellectual property rights, since plain packaging has a smothering effect on companies’ logos and trademarks.

A Commission spokeswoman said Brussels was in direct dialogue with the Australian government in respect of intellectual property ramifications of any plain-packaging proposal.

“The EU also asked Australia for more information on how its commitments under other WTO agreements, such as the Agreement on Trade-Related Aspects of Intellectual Property Rights, had been taken into account,” she said.

http://www.euractiv.com/health/tobacco-lobby-threatens-eu-plain-packaging-news-508891

Australian anti-smoking law bans brand labels

Friday 11 November 2011

http://www.independent.co.uk/life-style/health-and-families/health-news/australian-antismoking-law-bans-brand-labels-6260448.html

Laws banning brand labels on cigarette packages passed their last major legislative hurdle in the Australian Senate yesterday and immediately faced the threat of court action from tobacco firms.

From December next year cigarettes must be sold in plain olive packets, with no brand logos, and show graphic images of the harm smoking can cause. The legislation now returns to the lower house for a vote seen as a formality.

Australia poised to fight big tobacco in courts

http://www.3news.co.nz/Australia-poised-to-fight-big-tobacco-in-courts/tabid/417/articleID/232416/Default.aspx

Fri, 11 Nov 2011 1:24p.m.

By Rod McGuirk

The Australian government says it is ready to fight big tobacco companies in court to enact the world’s toughest laws on cigarette promotion – rules that will ban logos and other advertising on cigarette packs.

The Senate has passed in an amended form legislation that will prohibit tobacco companies from displaying their distinctive colours, brand designs and logos on cigarette packs in a bid to make smoking less attractive to the young. The legislation is expected to become law with the House of Representatives accepting the amendment later this month.

Cigarettes would be sold in drab, olive green packs, with brand names dwarfed by health warnings and graphic images of smoking’s consequences.

The government said that the laws will come into force in December 2012.

Tobacco giants argue that the move illegally diminishes the value of their trademarks. They have threatened a court battle for billions of dollars in compensation.

Health Minister Nicola Roxon said her government was “determined to take away the last method of advertising” cigarettes in Australia.

“We’re not going to be bullied into not taking this action just because tobacco companies say they might fight us in the courts,” she told reporters. “We’re ready for that if they do take legal action.”

British American Tobacco Australia Ltd., the Australian market leader, has warned it will soon challenge the law in the Australian High Court, and claimed the government was on “shaky legal ground”.

“No other country in the world has implemented plain packaging and there are many good reasons for that,” spokesman Scott McIntyre said in a statement.

Australia is a relatively small tobacco market, where the rate of smokers is 17 percent and falling, compared with around 20 percent of American adults. But tobacco companies fear that if Australia’s law stands, countries with more lucrative and growing markets could adopt the same strategy.

The warnings and often gruesome, full-colour images of the consequences of smoking, such as mouth cancer and gangrenous toes, will cover 75 percent of the packs’ front. Graphic health warnings currently cover only 30 percent.

Offenders will face fines of up to AU$1.1 million for a company and AU$220,000 for an individual. Australia already bans advertising at the point of sale.

Hong Kong-based Philip Morris Asia Limited, which owns the Australian affiliate Philip Morris Limited, filed a notice of claim against the government in an Australian court in June arguing that the legislation violates a bilateral investment treaty between Australia and Hong Kong.

Philip Morris says the treaty protects companies’ property, including intellectual property such as trademarks. It says plain packaging severely diminishes the value of the company’s trademark.

Read more: http://www.3news.co.nz/Australia-poised-to-fight-big-tobacco-in-courts/tabid/417/articleID/232416/Default.aspx#ixzz1dM971Dqv

Australia Cigarette Plain Packaging Law Passed, Tobacco Companies Vow to Fight

http://www.ibtimes.com/articles/247367/20111110/australia-cigarette-plain-packaging-law-passed-tobacco.htm

Australia became the first country to ban all colorful logos and other branding on the outside of cigarette packages Thursday. New legislation states that all cigarettes must be sold in plain packaging starting in December of next year.

(Photo: Reuters/Ho New)<br>Australia became the first country to ban all colorful logos and other branding on the outside of cigarette packages Thursday. New legislation states that all cigarettes must be sold in plain packaging starting in December of next year.

Australia became the first country to ban all colorful logos and other branding on the outside of cigarette packages Thursday. New legislation states that all cigarettes must be sold in plain packaging starting in December of next year.

According to the bill, the retail packaging of cigarette cartons will now have a matt finish and be a drab dark brown. The packaging will list health warnings and may display graphic images, but the brand of the company will be printed in plain white typeface. No trademarks may appear on the product.

The measures were passed Thursday in an effort to make cigarettes less enticing for children and young adults.Australian legislators hope the new regulations will decrease the likelihood that younger citizens will start smoking, thereby diminishing the number of smokers in Australia and the costly side effects that create major health problems.

Tobacco companies, on the other hand, are worried that plain packaging will impact their sales and have threated court action to question the legality of the new law. British American Tobacco, Britain’s Imperial Tobacco and Philip Morris seek billions in compensation, claiming that the regulations restrict their intellectual property rights, reported Reuters.

“Big tobacco has been fuming since day one that this is a law that they don’t want introduced. They want to keep selling their deadly products, and we want to reduce their market. So we are destined to disagree,” Health Minister Nicola Roxon told Reuters.

The law has been closely watched by legislators and lobby groups in other countries, including Europe, Canada and New Zealand in particular. Bhutan has already banned the sale of tobacco since June 2010. Other countries are trying to determine how tightly they can restrict tobacco sales without violating trademark and intellectual property laws.

“British American Tobacco Australia has always said that it wanted to avoid having to go to court but, if pushed to do so, it will take all appropriate legal measures to defend its intellectual property, valuable brands and right to compete as a legitimate business selling a legal product,” British American Tobacco Australia said in a statement to Reuters.

To report problems or to leave feedback about this article, e-mail: j.greenberg@ibtimes.com

To contact the editor, e-mail: editor@ibtimes.com

Legislation Passed: Australia Leads World in Plain Packaging of Tobacco

http://www.transformingthenation.com.au/2011/11/legislation-passed-australia-leads-world-in-plain-packaging-of-tobacco/

730510_58334980

On 10 November, the Gillard Government’s tobacco plain packaging legislation was passed. This means from 1 December 2012 all tobacco products sold in Australia will be in brand-free, olive-brown casing.

Minister for Health and Ageing, Nicola Roxon, proudly announced, “Today, the Australian Senate passed one of the most significant public health measures in its history – legislation requiring the plain packaging of tobacco products,” “Plain packaging means that the glamour is gone from smoking and cigarettes are now exposed for what they are: killer products that destroy thousands of Australian families.”

In essence, the laws hope to expose how harmful tobacco can be to national health both short and long term, and ultimately hope to prevent youth from picking up the habit. The question remains, however, how successful are the laws going to be in terms of how they affect those already hooked?

Packaging remains one of the last powerful marketing tools for tobacco companies to sell their products – so what now for those ruling the smoking empire? British American Tobacco Australia is clearly unimpressed and ready for the fight. The company alleges they will start legal proceedings once plain packaging becomes law. According to British American Tobacco, it is illegitimate to strip bare packaging of trademark’s and colour branding under the premise of intellectual property infringement.

Despite legal threats by bitter tobacco companies, Ms Roxon stands her ground. “Let there be no mistake, big tobacco is fighting against the Government for one very simple reason – because it knows, as we do, that plain packaging will work. While it is fighting to protect its profits, we are fighting to protect lives,” she said, “The World Health organization has recognized Australia’s lead in tobacco control, singling out our plain packaging legislation as an example for the world to follow.”

Photo courtesy: Somandjinn

http://www.sxc.hu/profile/somadjinn

Govt won’t be bullied by tobacco: Roxon

http://news.smh.com.au/breaking-news-national/govt-wont-be-bullied-by-tobacco-roxon-20111110-1n8ho.html

The federal government will not be bullied by tobacco companies into backing away from tobacco reforms due to be passed by the Senate on Thursday.

Australia will become the first country in the world to pass legislation requiring all cigarettes to be sold in plain packs devoid of branding, when it passes the Senate, as expected, following limited debate.

Big tobacco has vowed to challenge plain packaging in the courts once the legislation passes parliament.

Federal Health Minister Nicola Roxon said the government and big tobacco were destined to disagree.

“But we’re not going to be bullied into not taking this action just because the tobacco companies say they might fight us in the courts,” she told reporters in Melbourne on Thursday.

“We’re ready for that if they take legal action. We hope that they don’t. We believe that this is a measure that’s in the interests of the community and it would be better off for tobacco companies to look at ways they could invest in something that’s not so harmful for the community.”

British American Tobacco Australia insists the Commonwealth will be unlawfully acquiring its intellectual property rights and could have to pay billions of dollars in compensation.

Ms Roxon said the government didn’t accept that argument.

“They’re using that as a way of threatening both the government and the Senate to try not to proceed with this law,” she said.

The coalition supports the main plain packaging legislation but not an associated trademarks bill.

The health minister urged the Liberal senators to support the entirety of the legislation, but said that ultimately the government was confident it had the numbers to pass it.

Report of the Bills Committee on Dutiable Commodities (Amendment) Bill 2011

Purpose
This paper reports on the deliberations of the Bills Committee on
Dutiable Commodities (Amendment) Bill 2011 (the Bills Committee).

PurposeThis paper reports on the deliberations of the Bills Committee onDutiable Commodities (Amendment) Bill 2011 (the Bills Committee).

Download PDF : bc050615cb1-2339-e

Cigarettes and free speech: Judge blocks graphic smoking warnings

http://www.latimes.com/health/boostershots/la-heb-fda-cigarette-smoking-labels-20111107,0,5209487.story?track=rss

Graphic images cigarette warning labels

Shown are two of the nine graphic warning labels that cigarette makers would be required to use by the fall of 2012. A judge temporarily blocked that requirement Monday.

By Amina Khan, Los Angeles Times / for the Booster Shots blog

November 7, 2011, 1:52 p.m.

A federal judge has put a temporary block on new graphic warning labels for cigarette packages as a case concerning the constitutionality of requiring the labels proceeds.

Cigarettes to self-extinguish thanks to new paper

http://www.irishexaminer.com/breakingnews/ireland/cigarettes-to-self-extinguish-thanks-to-new-paper-526772.html

Wednesday, November 02, 2011 – 11:21 AM

A new EU regulation means cigarettes being smoked indoors will self-extinguish if they are not picked up.

The regulation requires all cigarettes sold across the EU to be modified from November 17 to reduce the risk of an accidental fire as a result of a burning cigarette being left at rest.

When smoked normally, the new “Low Ignition Propensity” (LIP) cigarettes should not go out, but they are designed to do so when left at rest due to a new cigarette paper that contains narrow bands which act as “speed bumps”.

A lit cigarette abandoned outside will not self-extinguish, as the movement of air will keep it lit. If left at rest indoors however, the cigarette is designed to self-extinguish as soon as it burns back to one of the two “speed bumps” (see picture).

Irish retailers are already selling the cigarettes as the new designs are phased in. A similar regulation is already in force in the US, Canada and Finland.

A spokesman said smokers should not notice any difference in appearance, taste or flavour of their cigarettes.

Despite the change, smokers are advised to ensure they do not leave lit cigarettes unattended and extinguish cigarettes carefully.

The National Consumer Agency will enforce cigarette manufacturers’ compliance with the new regulation.

Read more: http://www.irishexaminer.com/breakingnews/ireland/cigarettes-to-self-extinguish-thanks-to-new-paper-526772.html#ixzz1cjBGAvmq

Plain packaging delayed by five months

http://news.smh.com.au/breaking-news-national/plain-packaging-delayed-by-five-months-20111102-1munj.html

Julian Drape

November 2, 2011 – 7:19PM

AAP

Labor’s legislation on plain packaging of cigarettes is set to pass parliament next week, but tobacco products won’t be sold in olive-brown packages until the end of 2012 – five months later than originally planned.

The federal government says it will ram the draft laws through the Senate next Thursday with a “limited” debate followed by a vote.

The coalition supports the main plain packaging legislation but not an associated trademarks bill.

However, both will pass the Senate with the support of the Greens.

Cigarettes were to be sold in plain packs from July 1 next year but Health Minister Nicola Roxon announced on Wednesday that implementation would be pushed back until December 1.

Ms Roxon said the delay was necessary because it had taken longer than expected for the upper house to pass the legislation after it sailed through the House of Representatives in August.

“(But) that’s a small setback,” she told reporters in Canberra.

“Having a few last gasps for the tobacco companies doesn’t stop the fact we are going to put an end to marketing of tobacco products in Australia.”

Ms Roxon said there had been a lot of shenanigans in the Senate “and a lack of enthusiasm on the part of the Liberal Party” to pass the bills.

But opposition health spokesman Peter Dutton rubbished that claim.

Mr Dutton said Labor had delayed its own bill because it had other priorities – namely passing the controversial carbon tax legislation which has dominated debate in the upper house this week.

“The government runs the agenda in the Senate,” Mr Dutton told reporters.

“We want to see a reduction of smoking rates in our country.”

Under Labor’s revised timeline, the preliminary provisions of the plain packaging legislation will now come into effect when they receive royal assent – rather than on January 1.

Manufacturers will have to produce plain packets from October 1 next year instead of May 20, while retailers will be banned from selling any branded stock from December 1 instead of July 1.

Big tobacco has welcomed the delay but says cigarette makers need more time still to prepare.

Imperial Tobacco insists it needs up to 17 months from when the legislation is finalised.

“December 1, 2012, remains an impossible deadline,” Imperial spokeswoman Sonia Stewart said in a statement.

British American Tobacco Australia (BATA) told a parliamentary inquiry in August that manufacturers and retailers should be given until 2014 to make the change to plain packs.

The company has also vowed to challenge the world-first legislation in court once it passes parliament.

BATA argues that the commonwealth is planning to unlawfully acquire its intellectual property rights.

© 2011 AAP