Download PDF : d2b856c6-3294-4f32-d32d-cd2f95e86ed5
Legislation
Tasmania smokefree generation – why not in Hong Kong too ?
A debate has just concluded in the Upper House of the Tasmanian Parliament. The motion was:
That the Legislative Council calls on the Government to initiate and promote measures, including if necessary further legislative measures, to restrict access to tobacco products and reduce smoking and the harmful effects of smoking by
(1) Supporting a tobacco free generation of children born this century in Tasmania;
(2) Banning flavourings, additives and filter ventilation (including menthol) in tobacco products
sold in Tasmania;
(3) Progressively reducing the availability of tobacco products in Tasmania;
(4) Requiring the Education Department to implement evidence-based, monitored and evaluated
anti-tobacco education and smoking cessation programs in all government schools on an
ongoing basis.
After extensive debate, the motion was carried on the voices, with none against. This is especially interesting as almost all members of the Upper House are independent. The sole Government representative announced that the measure has the Government’s support.
Tobacco: public health comes first
http://afr.com/p/opinion/tobacco_public_health_comes_first_8GxRtCt7gyEc7S42hkPBsK
PUBLISHED: 17 Aug 2012 00:08:31 | UPDATED: 17 Aug 2012 00:32:55PUBLISHED: 17 Aug 2012PRINT EDITION: 17 Aug 2012
Share Links:email
The Australian Financial Review
Tobacco companies are understandably alarmed that the federal government’s legislation for plain packaging of cigarettes could be replicated by Britain, New Zealand, India and the European Union, among others.(HKG ?) After the High Court rejected the tobacco companies’ argument that they were entitled to compensation because the laws constituted an acquisition of their intellectual property, from December 1 tobacco products will have to be sold in packaging with no distinguishing brand marks.
Tobacco companies are pursuing other legal avenues, including challenging the laws under a bilateral investment treaty with Hong Kong, and in the World Trade Organisation.
This newspaper favours the use of market mechanisms to achieve policy outcomes rather than the imposition of regulations that restrict the use of private property. While the government does have a legitimate interest in public health, individuals also have a right to decide their tobacco use.
The plain-packaging laws don’t impinge on personal use, but they do take the drastic step of allowing the commonwealth to limit the use of trademarks in which the tobacco companies have invested heavily. And the Australian Industry Group raises a valid concern that the precedent could be used against other goods. There is already pressure to impose tougher regulation on fast food and alcohol.
However, Australia has had some big wins in improving public health through regulation, for example by imposing seatbelt laws. High taxes on tobacco products have helped cut the incidence of smoking by half, to about 15 per cent of the population. Given that there is no safe way to consume tobacco products, and that smoking-related expenses are at least $12 billion a year, taxes would have to double to cover the cost of health problems tobacco creates. In that situation, the plain-packaging laws may be a necessary evil.
Tobacco-control legislation under preparation: report
http://news.xinhuanet.com/english/china/2012-07/13/c_131713765.htm
BEIJING, July 13 (Xinhua) — A senior legislator said China’s top legislature is actively preparing to introduce more tobacco-control legislation, after a smoking ban in indoor public places seems ineffective, the People’s Daily reported Friday.
China lacks specialized laws on tobacco control which makes it hard to enforce the bans on smoking in public places, Han Qide, vice chairman of the National People’s Congress (NPC) Standing Committee, said Thursday at a forum on smoking control, according to the report.
Special research teams have been sent to some developed countries to conduct surveys and acquire knowledge, Han said.
The Ministry of Health (MOH) issued regulations last year banning smoking in all enclosed public locations including hotels, restaurants and theaters.
But Han noted that the warning pictures on cigarette packs were not printed, or printed but not in an eye-catching way.
“Inadequate publicity leads to people’s unawareness of smoking-related harm to health so that there is not a high public support to the smoking cessation measures,” Han was quoted as saying.
The central government had promised a smoke-free public spaces by including a public smoking ban in its 12th Five-year Plan (2011-2015) last March.
Some believe the whopping taxes and profits created by China’s tobacco industry also pose challenges for public smoking prohibition.
China is the largest tobacco-producing and -consuming country in the world, with more than 300 million smokers and another 740 million people exposed to second-hand smoke, according to an MOH report released in May.
Teen pushed Brookline bylaw raising tobacco-buying age
Essdras M Suarez/Globe Staff
Eric Dumas learned the antismoking lesson at an early age.
BROOKLINE – When Eric Dumas was 4, he asked his father if a man standing nearby was going to die. Taken aback, his father, Rob, inquired why his son would ask such a question. His son’s response: “That person is smoking.’’
“I thought, ‘Oh my God, maybe I have gone too far,’ ’’ Rob said, referring to the “smoking-is-bad message’’ he engrained in his son as a toddler. “But I think I got the message through.’’
The message stuck. Dumas, now 18 and a recent graduate of Brookline High School, persuaded Brookline’s Town Meeting to raise the legal age for buying tobacco products from 18 to 19. The town bylaw change, approved by a 169-1 vote May 25, now needs approval by the state attorney general before the 31 retailers that carry tobacco products in Brookline must stop selling them to 18-year-olds.
Dumas and Brookline High School administrators say they hope increasing the tobacco buyer age will cut down on the number of students who smoke outside while chatting on cement benches across from the school’s main doors.
Sitting in a school hallway after graduation rehearsal last week, Dumas said the outdoor smoking scene was the first thing he noticed when he arrived at Brookline High. Four years later, he says smoking isn’t actually a huge problem at the school – a 2011 survey found 11 percent of the school’s 2,000 students had smoked in the past 30 days. Yet Dumas believes he can help his peers kick the habit.
‘It isn’t something that we should just let grow.’
Eric Dumas On smoking
“It isn’t something that we should just let grow,’’ he said. “It is something you can put a lid on and stop.’’
Attempts to discourage teen smoking are not limited to Brookline.
Needham was the first town in Massachusetts to raise the tobacco buyer age to 19 in 2001. The town then upped the age to 20 in 2002 and 21 in 2003. Dumas hopes Brookline High students will use that model next year as an example and campaign to raise Brookline’s tobacco buyer age to 20.
In early May, Belmont raised its tobacco buyer age to 19 after the Board of Health heard about Dumas’s efforts. Arlington and Watertown officials are also thinking about implementing a similar policy.
Dumas – who played on the football, basketball, and baseball teams – first got involved with antismoking efforts in his sophomore year, when he joined the school’s Peer Leadership program, a class in which 60 students discuss how to discourage smoking and drinking. The class met three times a week at 7:20 a.m. –50 minutes before school starts.
“The fact that these kids are getting up at an ungodly hour shows their commitment,’’ says Hope Schroy, a Peer Leadership adviser.
With Schroy’s help, the students successfully lobbied school administrators to restrict student smokers to one corner of the public property across the street. They also proposed a town article that prohibits Brookline pharmacies from selling tobacco products. As a result, the CVS near the school now carries smoking cessation products instead of cigarettes.
Even town visitors have noticed the group’s efforts, Dumas said. “My friend was telling me the other day he went to CVS, and some guy from Virginia was in front of him and was outraged that he couldn’t buy cigarettes,’’ he said.
In March, the Peer Leaders tackled a new proposal to raise Brookline’s tobacco buyer age to 19, up from the age 18 requirement in state law.The Peer Leaders needed an 18-year-old registered voter to sponsor the petition, and Dumas volunteered.
Until then, smoking had not been a big issue in the Dumas family. No one in the house smokes, and no family members have died from smoking-related illnesses.
When Eric came downstairs one night with a tie on, it caught his father off guard.
“He’s saying, ‘I’ve got to go out tonight,’ and I ask, ‘Where are you going?’ ‘I’m going to Town Meeting.’ I’m like, ‘You go!’ ’’ About 10 Peer Leaders attended the meeting with Dumas.
Alan Balsam, director of Brookline’s Public Health and Human Services, who helped Dumas craft the bylaw, said Dumas’s role as a star player helped draw attention to the tobacco policy. “I think when Eric and his friends speak it resonates with his peers and the community at large,’’ Balsam said.
But not all Brookline students were pleased.
Gabriella Zutrau, 18, said the proposed change won’t stop teens from smoking because seniors will go to Allston to buy cigarettes and give them to underclassmen. “It will look good for the town,’’ she said. “But that’s all it will do.’’
Will Cooper, 16, said he smokes about six or seven cigarettes a week and wasn’t pleased with Dumas’s efforts. He said some of his friends under age 18 are upset about the age increase because they are “hooked on cigarettes and don’t want to wait that extra year.’’
Still, Dumas said there has been no large public outcry. After the article passed at the Town Meeting, he said, he saw only one Facebook post by a student against the proposal.
Tharindu Weeresinghe, a Peer Leader who has been friends with Dumas since fourth grade, worked closely with Dumas on the article. Weeresinghe praised Dumas, who is known among students for his athletic success, for taking on the smoking issue. “Even his success in sports hasn’t changed the person he is. He’s always willing to give a helping hand,’’ Weeresinghe said.
Next fall, Dumas will attend Wheaton College in Norton, where he plans to pitch for the baseball team and study international relations. He envisions a career in law enforcement; his dream job is to work for the FBI.
Joe Campagna, the Brookline High varsity baseball coach, who has coached Dumas since age 7, did not know about his pitcher’s tobacco policy work but said it was not a surprise.
“He’s got a very endearing personality,’’ he said. “Kids respect him on the team.’’
Campagna said he had to drop one of his players this year because the student was caught in violation of smoking.
“I see plenty of kids with cigarettes in their mouth,’’ he said. “It’s pretty disturbing.’’
Tobacco Plain Packaging Amendment Regulation 2012 (No. 1)
| http://www.comlaw.gov.au/Details/F2012L00563
Download PDF : C2011A00148 Download PDF : F2011L02644 |
Global Tobacco Industry Fights to Subvert Control Laws
http://www.asiasentinel.com/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=4553&Itemid=404
| Health Policies Decided By Tobacco Companies Tobacco products are the only legally available products that can kill up to one half of their regular users if consumed as recommended by the manufacturer, according to the International Union Against Tuberculosis and Lung Disease. “With its formidable economic and political resources, the tobacco industry is fighting to prevent passage of new tobacco control laws and policies around the world,” according to the International Union. “Article 5.3 of the Framework Convention on Tobacco Control calls for parties to the treaty to resist these efforts to undermine public health and continue the spiraling pandemic of tobacco-related disease.” There is a fundamental conflict of interest between the goals of the tobacco industry and the goals of governments in promoting public health. The industry’s interference has, time and again, weakened and delayed the enforcement of public health policies around the world. It is because of this interference that in India strong pictorial warnings on tobacco packs have been diluted and/or their implementation postponed several times in the past. In November 2008, The Indian Ministry of Health and Family Welfare revealed before the Central Information Commission that tobacco industry is putting “pressure” to relax the tobacco control policies, according to The Hindu, 14 November 2008. In fact the tobacco industry, Indian Hotel Association and other allied agencies had filed more than 70 court cases against tobacco control policies in Indian courts in September 2008, and due to aggressive lobbying by such agencies, the Group of Ministers formed earlier to review the pictorial warnings on tobacco products, diluted the pictorial warnings provision and postponed the implementation of pictorial warnings on tobacco products at least six-times. Jagdeep Singh Rana of the Union says that ‘Tobacco industry people have been approaching various sections of officials and activists in Chandigarh (the first Indian city to go smoke-free in 2007) to find support for dilution/ defeating the initiative to license tobacco vendors. Many attempts were made by the industry in this regard in the past.’ Apart from interfering directly in policy making and devising ways to circumvent the existing tobacco control laws, the tobacco giants under the garb of corporate social responsibility are active in sponsoring/financing not only social activities like film/music concerts/sports events, but also funding educational activities. One such example is the Godfrey Phillip Bravery Awards (given for acts of physical and social bravery and humanitarian service) instituted in India in 1990. Godfrey Phillips India states as its core philosophy “Making a better world for a better tomorrow.” Through all such promotional campaigns, the tobacco industry blatantly washes off its sins in public with the air of a do-gooder and gets away with it too. It makes a mockery of tobacco control efforts and puts the peddlers of death on a pedestal. In China, which boasts 350 million smokers and nearly 1.2 million smoking related deaths every year, it is a different story altogether with the government being in conflict with itself over health policies as it is the sole owner of the tobacco industry. The industry is very strong in terms of the huge quantity of the cigarettes produced. So it is not surprising that government efforts to bring down the incidence of smoking are weak and half-hearted. Indonesia, the third largest consumer of tobacco, has not signed the Framework Convention on Tobacco Control. Popular music/sports/cultural events which mainly attract teenagers are sponsored by tobacco companies with a view to market their products to young, potential new customers. There is no ban on advertising tobacco on street billboards or night time television. The result of aggressive marketing and promotional strategies targeting women, children and youth is obvious. Indonesia has the world’s highest percentage of young smokers with an estimated one million smokers being less than 16 years of age. Irina Berezhnova, Director of The Union Russia Office, says that, “In Russia the tobacco corporate fund social activities to improve environment, education, poverty reduction, and finance art events and institutions. Likewise, Mirta Molinari of the Union says: “in Latin American countries they help governments under the garb of Corporate Social Responsibility with the sole aim of circumventing existing legislation, delaying implementation of tax increase and smoke free policy and promoting their products to increase the consumption mainly amongst youths and women.” According to Tara Singh Bam, Technical Advisor at the Union, who is involved with tobacco control activities in Indonesia and Nepal, “In Nepal the tobacco industry lobbies with the officials of the Ministries of Finance, Health and Population, and of Law and Justice and also funds sports activities. Tobacco tax is still low in Nepal because the tobacco industry is a member of the tax committee under Ministry of Finance. It has also entered into litigation with the Ministry of Health and the government to delay implementation of pictorial health warnings occupying 75% area of tobacco packs and the matter is pending in the Supreme Court of Nepal.” In Australia the industry’s opposition to plain tobacco packaging has been deviously aggressive and includes legal and economic threats, funding front groups of retailers and think tanks to oppose health policies, making political donations, funding legal actions against the government using trade treaties, and funding mass media campaigns calling Australia a nanny state. Ehsaan Latif, Director of Tobacco Control at the Union would like governments to be very transparent in their dealings with the tobacco industry, as Article 5.3 under FCTC says that tobacco industry should not be involved in framing health policies. He says that, “It is the duty of the states to protect public health policy from public health interference of the industry. The state should share with the civil society every direction that they have with the tobacco industry and harness the expertise and technical knowledge available with the civil society in countering this epidemic. But what we want is a complete ban on tobacco advertising and sponsorship.” It is vital to understand that unless all such covert and blatant tobacco industry interference in public health policies is checked, the implementation of other health interventions (smoke-free policies, pictorial warnings on tobacco products, ban on tobacco advertising, promotion and sponsorship) will continue to be weakened, slowed and challenged. It is important to counteract the false propaganda of the tobacco giants with the existing evidence based information, and to inform the public and the media about their tactics which undermine public health policies. “Industry interference is the number one obstacle to the implementation and enforcement of the global tobacco treaty,” said Kathy Mulvey, international policy director of Corporate Accountability International. “Article 5.3 is the lynchpin of the treaty, determining whether or not countries will be able to reverse this preventable epidemic without the tobacco industry standing in their way.” Anne Jones, CEO of ASH Australia said: “Governments must put health first and ahead of the vested interests of an industry that targets children and promotes lethal products that kill and rob people of their good health and years of life. Governments must stand together and fight the rapacious industry by protecting health policies from tobacco industry interference.” (Shobha Shukla is the Managing Editor of Citizen News Service. Email: shobha@citizen-news.org This e-mail address is being protected from spam bots, you need JavaScript enabled to view it , website: http://www.citizen-news.org) |
Metal cigarette packets: retailers could get burned
Metal cigarette packets: retailers could get burned
May 31, 2012
AT LEAST one tobacco company has moved to frustrate the impact of the Gillard government’s plain packaging laws by distributing metal cigarette packets for sale.
The Peter Stuyvesant-branded metal packets are now available for sale before the new regulations – due to take effect in December – which will outlaw the sale of packets bearing any brand or logo.The Health Minister, Tanya Plibersek, warned retailers not to get burned by stocking metal cigarette tins that would not comply with the plain packaging regulations, due to take effect in December, and would become illegal to sell.
However, while the law may prevent sale, it will not prohibit people continually using the metal packet to hold their cigarettes.
The government is also about to introduce draconian penalties against tobacco smugglers, following industry claims that plain packaging would see an influx of black market tobacco. The attorney-general will today announce jail terms of up to 10 years for smuggling tobacco as part of tougher customs laws which will create a specific new offence aimed at black market tobacco traders.
Penalties range from two to five times the amount of duty evaded. Tobacco bought overseas is liable for a $420 excise duty.
Mark Metherell
Drug for smokers to quit could be a drag on resources
| Proposal to put medicine to beat addiction on the ‘essential’ catalogue splits the health community | |||||
| Zhuang Pinghui May 31, 2012 |
|
||||
|
Beijing’s municipal Legislative Affairs Office has released draft tobacco control legislation requiring medical institutions to provide “guidance and help” for smokers. The draft, released for public consultation last week, echoes a controversial plan first outlined by Health Minister Chen Zhu in April that would see consultations with doctors on quitting smoking covered by basic medical insurance and the drugs involved in such treatment included in the essential drugs catalogue. While many doctors and tobacco control advocates support the plan, saying that giving smokers professional help to quit will improve public health and cut the social cost of tobacco use, others question whether it is appropriate to extend limited basic medical insurance to cover such drugs. The mainland is the world’s largest producer and consumer of tobacco, accounting for 40 per cent of cigarette sales. A Ministry of Health report in 2010 said there were more than 356 million smokers on the mainland and over a million smoking-related deaths every year. Wang Hongzhi , a pharmaceutical industry specialist at management consultancy Allpku, said using drugs to treat smoking addiction was ineffective, as clinical trials showed the most effective drug was only 10 percentage points more effective than a placebo. Authorities in other countries had also linked such drugs to suicidal tendencies and cardiovascular diseases, he said. And even though such drugs are covered by basic medical insurance in some countries, such as Australia, that did not necessarily mean Beijing should follow suit as the level of social security on the mainland was much lower, he said. The full course of treatment costs more than 4,000 yuan (HK$4,899), while the premium for basic medical insurance in rural areas is about 300 yuan a year, Wang said, adding that the reimbursement level for essential drugs in rural areas was only 50 per cent. He said that including drugs used in treating smoking addiction in the essential drugs catalogue should not be a priority, given that the mainland only extended insurance coverage to serious diseases such as kidney failure and lung cancer in March. “The point is you can’t quit smoking solely because of the drugs or willpower,” Wang said. “There are many other things that need to be addressed first, otherwise it is just not an efficient use of money.” But Dr Xiao Dan , director of the smoking cessation clinic at Beijing’s Chaoyang Hospital, said that extending insurance coverage should be a top priority as it was cheaper to treat tobacco addiction than to treat the cardiovascular diseases that would otherwise develop. Xiao said that some of her patients, after hearing that the first phase of drug treatment would cost them more than 2,100 yuan, would only accept one or two packets of drugs, or none at all, saying they would rely on willpower instead. “Smoking addiction is a chronic ailment and drug treatment is a way of treating it,” she said. “The priority of basic medical insurance should be to focus on the burden on people’s health, and smoking is responsible for an enormous [burden].” Xiao also said that helping smokers quit would be good news for the 740 million non-smokers on the mainland who had to put up with second-hand smoke. Some tobacco control experts who support the idea, such as Professor Zhi Xiuyi , director of the Lung Cancer Treatment Centre at Capital Medical University, propose a gradual approach. He said pilot programmes should first be conducted in designated cities that already have hospital-based smoking-cessation clinics, had introduced bans on smoking in public places and had higher levels of social security. That would let doctors identify patients suffering from serious addiction and those who should be treated with drugs. “Not all patients need to be treated with drugs, and we need to have trained, experienced doctors for that purpose,” Zhi said. Jiang Yuan , deputy director of the tobacco control office at the Chinese Centre for Disease Control and Prevention, said extending basic medical insurance to cover smoking cessation was only a small part of tobacco control and should only be implemented after other measures, such as bans on smoking in public areas, were in place, otherwise patients would just start smoking again. “Studies show tobacco prices, a ban on smoking in working areas and health warnings … are the three most effective measures to encourage people to quit,” she said. “We need to improve the general environment for tobacco control first.” |
|||||